In the October 2024 Kansas Legislative Division of Post Audit report *Estimating the Economic Impacts of Tax Increment Financing Districts* (R-24-012), the auditors addressed the “but-for” concept directly while explaining their methodology on costs.
They described the “but-for” percentage as an estimate of how likely it is that a given development would have happened without the public incentive. They noted that the economic rate of return on a city’s costs is tied to this percentage. They then stated that accurately estimating it is very difficult and requires substantial amounts of data. More importantly, they concluded that whether development would have occurred in any individual TIF district is an inherently unknowable question, because it depends heavily on the private business decisions of the developers themselves. For those reasons, the auditors said they did not analyze the “but-for” percentage for the audit question they were answering.
That is the full extent of their treatment. They recognized the concept, flagged the practical and conceptual problems with measuring it, and chose not to attempt the analysis. The report does not contain a finding that any specific Topeka project failed or passed a but-for test, nor does it recommend that cities adopt or abandon local but-for requirements. It simply records that the core counterfactual is hard to measure and, for individual projects, unknowable on the available evidence.
This is the language that has been used in the local discussion: the state’s nonpartisan auditors looked at the same idea Topeka requires private applicants to document (and pay a consultant to produce) and decided it was not something they could reliably quantify. Kansas law does not mandate a but-for test for TIF, CID, or RHID; Topeka added it through local policy.
Full report:
https://www.kslpa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/B01.01-Final-Report-1.pdf
Library page:
https://www.kslpa.gov/audit-report-library/estimating-the-economic-impacts-of-tax-increment-financing-districts/
