Tuesday, November 10, 2026

**The “but-for” discussion in the LPA audit is limited and cautious.**

In the October 2024 Kansas Legislative Division of Post Audit report *Estimating the Economic Impacts of Tax Increment Financing Districts* (R-24-012), the auditors addressed the “but-for” concept directly while explaining their methodology on costs.

They described the “but-for” percentage as an estimate of how likely it is that a given development would have happened without the public incentive. They noted that the economic rate of return on a city’s costs is tied to this percentage. They then stated that accurately estimating it is very difficult and requires substantial amounts of data. More importantly, they concluded that whether development would have occurred in any individual TIF district is an inherently unknowable question, because it depends heavily on the private business decisions of the developers themselves. For those reasons, the auditors said they did not analyze the “but-for” percentage for the audit question they were answering.

That is the full extent of their treatment. They recognized the concept, flagged the practical and conceptual problems with measuring it, and chose not to attempt the analysis. The report does not contain a finding that any specific Topeka project failed or passed a but-for test, nor does it recommend that cities adopt or abandon local but-for requirements. It simply records that the core counterfactual is hard to measure and, for individual projects, unknowable on the available evidence.

This is the language that has been used in the local discussion: the state’s nonpartisan auditors looked at the same idea Topeka requires private applicants to document (and pay a consultant to produce) and decided it was not something they could reliably quantify. Kansas law does not mandate a but-for test for TIF, CID, or RHID; Topeka added it through local policy.

Full report: 

https://www.kslpa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/B01.01-Final-Report-1.pdf  


Library page: 

 https://www.kslpa.gov/audit-report-library/estimating-the-economic-impacts-of-tax-increment-financing-districts/


 

https://share.google/aimode/iNEpqSuNBw9PZT1Xj

US bond yields surged after the October inflation report because consumer prices rose faster than expected, prompting investors to wager that the Federal Reserve will raise interest rates more aggressively at its December meeting. [1] (https://beinsure.com/news/us-treasury-yields-surge-as-cpi-inflation-exceeds-forecasts/), [2] (https://www.thestandard.com.hk/finance/article/348106/Yields-jump-as-consumer-price-inflation-in-October-beats-economists-expectations)
The Consumer Price Index (CPI) increased 0.4% in October, landing above the 0.3% forecast by economists. While this marked a slight deceleration from September’s 0.6% pace, core inflation (excluding volatile food and energy costs) remained persistent at 0.3%. This sticky inflationary data immediately triggered a bond market sell-off, pushing yields sharply higher across all maturities. [1] (https://www.wsj.com/articles/10-year-treasury-auction-needs-price-concession-for-smooth-absorption-58297cbc), [2] (https://finance.yahoo.com/video/treasury-yields-jump-inflation-fuels-161002514.html), [3] (https://beinsure.com/news/us-treasury-yields-surge-as-cpi-inflation-exceeds-forecasts/), [4] (https://www.thestandard.com.hk/finance/article/348106/Yields-jump-as-consumer-price-inflation-in-October-beats-economists-expectations)
The swift spike in Treasury yields was driven by three primary catalysts:
• Escalating Fed Rate Bets: Prior to the release, traders were already factoring in a hawkish stance from policymakers. Following the hot report, futures markets began aggressively pricing in tighter financial conditions, with growing speculation that the central bank could implement a larger-than-usual 50 basis point interest rate hike at its December 8–9 session. [1] (https://www.thestandard.com.hk/finance/article/348106/Yields-jump-as-consumer-price-inflation-in-October-beats-economists-expectations), [2] (https://beinsure.com/news/us-treasury-yields-surge-as-cpi-inflation-exceeds-forecasts/)
• Validation of Hawkish Fed Guidance: The hot inflation print directly validated recent warnings from Federal Reserve Governor Christopher Waller. Waller had explicitly stated that if core consumer prices rose by 0.3% or more, an upsized half-point rate increase would be firmly on the table for December. [1] (https://www.thestandard.com.hk/finance/article/348106/Yields-jump-as-consumer-price-inflation-in-October-beats-economists-expectations)
• Shorter-Term Policy Repricing: The 2-year Treasury note, which is highly sensitive to imminent changes in central bank policy, suffered the sharpest initial blow. Its yield jumped over 14 basis points to 4.691% as investors abandoned expectations of a near-term monetary pause. Concurrently, the benchmark 10-year Treasury yield surged by roughly 7 basis points, pushing toward 4.934% and intensifying pressure across broad equity markets. [1] (https://beinsure.com/news/us-treasury-yields-surge-as-cpi-inflation-exceeds-forecasts/), [2] (https://www.thestandard.com.hk/finance/article/348106/Yields-jump-as-consumer-price-inflation-in-October-beats-economists-expectations)
If you would like to explore the broader market fallout, let me know if I should detail:
How this yield spike is impacting major stock indexes and tech valuationsThe ripple effect on mortgage rates and consumer borrowing costsThe baseline economic projections leading into the December FOMC meeting


Henry McClure  
785.383.9994
sent from mobile 📱
time kills deals

Top Views

Kevin 

My blog has blown up and out of 55K views in the last seven day you are #1

Thanks 




H

Henry McClure 
Time Kills Deals 
762-291-2765 

444

RE: public comment

Henry,

 

This email confirms you are signed up to speak under Items 5A. Ardmore Walk Addition No. 1 RHID and  6. General Public Comment at the November 10, 2026, Governing Body meeting. The meeting begins at 6:00 p.m. in the City Council Chambers located at 214 SE 8th Street, 2nd Floor, Topeka KS. 

 

You will have 4 minutes to address the Governing Body for each item.

 

Per Governing Body Rule 5.5, public comments are limited to topics directly relevant to the business of the Governing Body.  Comments pertaining to personnel and litigation matters are not allowed.

 

Procedures for Addressing the Governing Body In accordance with Governing Body Rules 5.6 and 5.7, the following protocols for public comment apply:

 

•              Each person shall state his or her name and city of residence in an audible tone for the record.

•              All remarks shall be addressed to the Governing Body as a whole -- not to any individual member.

•              In order to provide additional time for as many individuals as possible to address the Governing Body, each individual signed up to speak will need to complete his or her comments within four minutes.

 

Per Governing Body Rule 5.7, the following behavior will not be tolerated from any speaker:

 

•              Uttering fighting words

•              Slander

•              Speeches invasive of the privacy of individuals (no mention of names) Unreasonably Loud Speech

•              Repetitious Speech or Debate

•              Speeches so disruptive of proceedings that the legislative process is substantially interrupted

 

Any speaker who engages in this type of behavior will be warned once by the presiding office (Mayor).  If the behavior continues, the speaker will be ordered to cease his or her behavior.  If the speaker persists in interfering with the ability of the Governing Body to carry out its function, he or she will be removed from the City Council Chambers or Zoom meeting room.

 

Thank you,

 

Megan Brunson

Administrative Officer, Special Events

mjbrunson@topeka.org

785-368-3940

 

“The preceding email message (including any attachments) contains information that may be confidential, protected by the attorney/client or other applicable privileges or that may constitute non-public information. This message is intended to be conveyed only to the designated recipient(s). If you are not listed as a recipient of this message, please notify the sender immediately by replying to this message and then delete it from your system. Use, dissemination, distribution, or reproduction of this message by unintended recipients is not authorized and may be unlawful.”

Uploaded Image

 

From: Henry McClure <mcre13@gmail.com>
Sent: Tuesday, November 10, 2026 2:16 PM
To: City Clerk <cclerk@topeka.org>; MCRE Media <mcre1.9999@blogger.com>
Subject: public comment

 

Notice: -----This message was sent by an external sender-----

 

Agenda Item 5.A – Ardmore Walk Addition No. 1 RHID (Step I) is the initial statutory step under the Kansas Reinvestment Housing Incentive District Act for a 42-home single-family subdivision.

 

I want to speak on the above issue

 

And

 

At the end of the meeting 

 

H

 

Henry McClure 

Time Kills Deals 

762-291-2765 

 

444

public comment

Agenda Item 5.A – Ardmore Walk Addition No. 1 RHID (Step I) is the initial statutory step under the Kansas Reinvestment Housing Incentive District Act for a 42-home single-family subdivision.

I want to speak on the above issue

And

At the end of the meeting 

H

Henry McClure 
Time Kills Deals 
762-291-2765 

444

RE: 1998.

Good afternoon,

Thank you for your message.  This message serves as confirmation that your email has been received by the council members. 

 

Tara Jefferies

Sr. Executive Assistant to the City Council

City of Topeka

215 SE 7th St, Room 211D

Topeka, KS 66603

785-368-3710

 

The preceding email message, including any attachments, contains information that may be confidential, protected by the attorney/client or other applicable privileges or that may constitute as non-public information. This message is intended to be conveyed only to the designated recipient(s). If you are not listed as a recipient of this message, please notify the sender immediately by replying to this message and then delete it from your system. Use, dissemination, distribution, or reproduction of this message by unintended recipients is not authorized and may be unlawful. 

 

Uploaded Image


 

 

 

 

 

 

From: Henry McClure <mcre13@gmail.com>
Sent: Tuesday, November 10, 2026 1:22 PM
To: Governing Body <governingbody@topeka.org>; City Clerk <cclerk@topeka.org>; MCRE Media <mcre1.9999@blogger.com>
Subject: 1998.

 

Notice: -----This message was sent by an external sender-----

 

 

The Kansas Rural Housing Incentive District Act (K.S.A. 12-5241 et seq.) was enacted in 1998 (1998 Session Laws Chapter 66, approved April 8, 1998). It took effect July 1 of that year. Its stated purpose was to encourage the development and renovation of housing in rural cities and counties by letting them finance public infrastructure (streets, utilities, site prep, etc.) that supports housing in places with a documented shortage of quality housing. It was designed as a targeted tax-increment tool for rural Kansas, where pure market conditions often would not produce new homes.

Was it successful over time?

It had a slow start and has been a useful but incomplete tool—not a transformative fix for rural housing or population trends.

  • Early years (late 1990s–mid-2000s): Relatively dormant. Use was limited and concentrated in southwest Kansas. One early notable application around 2007–2008 involved anticipated housing demand from a military base (soldiers finishing service and their families).
  • Growth phase (late 2000s onward): Interest rose as rural shortages, the “appraisal gap” (construction costs vs. what rural buyers can pay or appraisals support), and workforce needs became clearer. By the early 2020s, dozens of local governments had established districts; one Department of Commerce official described roughly 30 local units of government with over 80 RHIDs.

 

  • Local examples of impact:

 

    • Dodge City: 12 developed districts and more than 300 units by around 2019.
    • Emporia: Multiple subdivision projects (e.g., Hidden Vistas, Riverside, Pleasant Point) plus early upper-story downtown housing after later expansions.
    • Garden City: Officials have described RHID as the primary tool driving most local housing growth over the past decade (though overall production still lags projected need; roughly 1,200 units in the development queue at one point).
    • Hays (Tallgrass Addition) and other communities (Concordia, Newton, Pittsburg, etc.) have used it for infrastructure-supported subdivisions and some downtown conversions, generating local economic activity (construction jobs, sales tax, later full property-tax recovery).

The Legislature repeatedly expanded it because it was seen as worthwhile: population thresholds were raised, the capture period went from 15 to 25 years, upper-story housing in downtowns was added (around 2021), and in 2023 (SB 17) it was renamed the Reinvestment Housing Incentive District Act and broadened further (including to larger cities under unit caps). Topeka itself was specially included earlier via 2022 legislation.

 

Bottom line: RHID has enabled concrete housing projects and infrastructure financing in many rural Kansas communities that would otherwise have faced bigger barriers. It has not reversed broader rural depopulation trends or closed statewide housing shortages on its own—those continue for reasons including builder/labor capacity, costs, and market conditions. It works best as one tool alongside others (Moderate Income Housing grants, tax credits, etc.).

 

Rural housing needs remain significant, which is why the program keeps being adjusted and why places like Topeka sought access to it.

1998.


The Kansas Rural Housing Incentive District Act (K.S.A. 12-5241 et seq.) was enacted in 1998 (1998 Session Laws Chapter 66, approved April 8, 1998). It took effect July 1 of that year. Its stated purpose was to encourage the development and renovation of housing in rural cities and counties by letting them finance public infrastructure (streets, utilities, site prep, etc.) that supports housing in places with a documented shortage of quality housing. It was designed as a targeted tax-increment tool for rural Kansas, where pure market conditions often would not produce new homes.

Was it successful over time?

It had a slow start and has been a useful but incomplete tool—not a transformative fix for rural housing or population trends.
  • Early years (late 1990s–mid-2000s): Relatively dormant. Use was limited and concentrated in southwest Kansas. One early notable application around 2007–2008 involved anticipated housing demand from a military base (soldiers finishing service and their families).
  • Growth phase (late 2000s onward): Interest rose as rural shortages, the “appraisal gap” (construction costs vs. what rural buyers can pay or appraisals support), and workforce needs became clearer. By the early 2020s, dozens of local governments had established districts; one Department of Commerce official described roughly 30 local units of government with over 80 RHIDs.

  • Local examples of impact:

    • Dodge City: 12 developed districts and more than 300 units by around 2019.
    • Emporia: Multiple subdivision projects (e.g., Hidden Vistas, Riverside, Pleasant Point) plus early upper-story downtown housing after later expansions.
    • Garden City: Officials have described RHID as the primary tool driving most local housing growth over the past decade (though overall production still lags projected need; roughly 1,200 units in the development queue at one point).
    • Hays (Tallgrass Addition) and other communities (Concordia, Newton, Pittsburg, etc.) have used it for infrastructure-supported subdivisions and some downtown conversions, generating local economic activity (construction jobs, sales tax, later full property-tax recovery).
The Legislature repeatedly expanded it because it was seen as worthwhile: population thresholds were raised, the capture period went from 15 to 25 years, upper-story housing in downtowns was added (around 2021), and in 2023 (SB 17) it was renamed the Reinvestment Housing Incentive District Act and broadened further (including to larger cities under unit caps). Topeka itself was specially included earlier via 2022 legislation.

Bottom line: RHID has enabled concrete housing projects and infrastructure financing in many rural Kansas communities that would otherwise have faced bigger barriers. It has not reversed broader rural depopulation trends or closed statewide housing shortages on its own—those continue for reasons including builder/labor capacity, costs, and market conditions. It works best as one tool alongside others (Moderate Income Housing grants, tax credits, etc.).

Rural housing needs remain significant, which is why the program keeps being adjusted and why places like Topeka sought access to it.

RE: Are we over-incentivizing Columbia Capital?

    Leigha Boling Economic Development Director City of Topeka 215 SE 7th Street, Topeka, KS 66603 lboling@topeka.org ...