Monday, November 16, 2026

Re: Are we over-incentivizing Columbia Capital?

I'm asking Karen to get the data 

She does not have to go through KORA

I should NOT have to pay to educate Karen, my city council person 


Thanks 

From: Leigha Boling <lboling@topeka.org>
Sent: Monday, November 16, 2026 10:52 AM
To: Henry McClure <mcre13@gmail.com>; Karen A. Hiller <khiller@Topeka.org>
Cc: Michael A. Webb <mawebb@topeka.org>; Kelly J. Trussell <kjtrussell@topeka.org>; Braxton Copley <bcopley@topeka.org>
Subject: RE: Are we over-incentivizing Columbia Capital?
 

Good morning, Henry.

 

Thank you for your email and questions. I have forwarded the request to the Interim City Attorney for review and guidance regarding the appropriate process under the Kansas Open Records Act (KORA).

 

I will follow up once I have additional information.

Thank you,

Leigha Boling

Economic Development Director

City of Topeka

215 SE 7th Street, Topeka, KS 66603

lboling@topeka.org

Phone: (785) 368-0974

 

NOTICE: This message and any attachments may be confidential and contain legally privileged information. If you are not an employee of the City of Topeka (see K.S.A. 75-6102(d)), we do not waive any legal protection that may apply such as attorney-client or work product privileges. If you have received this email in error, please immediately notify the sender and delete the message and any attachments. Further, this communication is not intended to constitute, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice to you.

 

From: Henry McClure <mcre13@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, November 16, 2026 3:32 AM
To: Karen A. Hiller <khiller@topeka.org>
Cc: Leigha Boling <lboling@topeka.org>
Subject: Are we over-incentivizing Columbia Capital?

 

Notice: -----This message was sent by an external sender-----

 

Karen,

The City tells us the but-for test exists to make sure we don't over-incentivize a deal. I'd like to ask a fair question: are we over-incentivizing Columbia Capital?

The State of Kansas has already weighed in on the test itself. The Legislative Post Audit report R-24-012 called the but-for question "an inherently unknowable question." Yet Topeka requires developers to post a $25,000 deposit for a TIF application and $25,000 to $50,000 per RHID plan, largely to pay a consultant to answer it.

Public records show what this kind of work costs elsewhere:

- Canyon Research performed a STAR bond feasibility study for Overland Park for a flat $7,000.
- Baker Tilly reviewed a but-for analysis for Joplin, Missouri on an hourly basis ($160 to $235 for analysts, $295 to $525 for partners).
- Columbia Capital itself charged Harvey County, Kansas $15,000 plus $0.90 per $1,000 of bonds in 2026.

Topeka's contract and fee schedule with Columbia Capital have not been made public, and members of Policy & Finance asked staff for that contract on November 4.

I'd appreciate your help getting answers to four questions:

1. What are the City's current contract and fee schedule with Columbia Capital?
2. What has the City paid Columbia Capital since 2017, and how much of that was passed through to developers?
3. When was this work last put out for competitive bid, and which firms responded?
4. Will the City commit to bidding future gap and but-for reviews competitively, including firms like Canyon Research and Baker Tilly?

If the goal is to avoid over-incentivizing developers, the same discipline should apply to the consultant. A city that needs housing shouldn't ask local builders to pay top dollar for an answer the State says can't be known. Every dollar spent on studies is a dollar that doesn't go into the ground.

I've copied Leigha Boling so staff can help with the records.

Thank you for your leadership on this.

Respectfully,

 

Henry McClure 

Time kills deals

785-383-9994

 

No comments:

RE: Are we over-incentivizing Columbia Capital?

    Leigha Boling Economic Development Director City of Topeka 215 SE 7th Street, Topeka, KS 66603 lboling@topeka.org ...