Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Butt sore

Unnecessary Local Barriers Are Costing Topeka Growth

Kansas law does not require a "but-for" test for TIF, CID, or RHID projects. The state statutes set the framework. Cities may add their own policies, but they are not obligated to. Topeka chose to create an extra layer, and that choice has real consequences.

The but-for standard asks whether a project would happen without public assistance. In report R-24-012, the Kansas Legislative Division of Post Audit described this as an inherently unknowable question. It depends on private business decisions that cannot be fully observed or predicted. Academic research on incentives, including work by Timothy Bartik of the Upjohn Institute, finds that typical but-for percentages fall in a low range, often 2 to 25 percent. In most cases the project would have gone ahead anyway. A local requirement that forces developers to prove the unknowable simply adds cost, time, and uncertainty.

Some will point out that the auditors did not recommend eliminating the test. They didn't have to. They told us the question can't be answered, and what to do with that finding is up to the Governing Body.

Topeka's local policy applies this test to private applicants. In practice it has used return benchmarks, such as the roughly 8.5 percent capitalization rate in recent reviews, and it relies on outside analysis, often from Columbia Capital Management and Jeff White. Private developers pay application and funding fees that have gone up, plus the cost of consultant review. The public record has not shown the same standard applied with equal rigor to projects involving the City or GO Topeka.

Municipal advisory services are available from many firms, and fees are negotiable. When one firm becomes the default reviewer for an extra local test the state does not require, the process itself generates revenue for consultants while raising the hurdle for the private sector. Each added fee, study, and approval step raises the total cost of a project. Higher costs mean fewer projects get finished. Fewer projects mean less private capital, fewer jobs, a smaller tax base, and slower growth.

Free enterprise responds to the conditions it actually faces. When cities lower unnecessary barriers with streamlined approvals, fewer subjective tests, and competitive professional fees, private investment increases. Capital is mobile, and developers and businesses compare locations. Places that treat the private sector as a partner rather than a source of fees and process tend to attract more activity. Places that layer local rules on top of state law and then route the analysis through preferred consultants tend to grow more slowly.

The Governor and the Department of Commerce operate under the statutes the Legislature wrote. Those statutes do not impose the but-for requirement Topeka adopted. Local officials who add it are choosing a stricter standard than the one the state itself uses. That is a policy decision, not a legal mandate, and the Governing Body can reverse it.

A straightforward change would bring Topeka in line with state law:

- Retire the local but-for requirement for private TIF, CID, and RHID applications, or apply any remaining review uniformly and transparently to every project, including those involving public entities.
- Publish the amounts paid to outside advisors for incentive analysis.
- Limit fees to actual, competitive costs rather than an open-ended process.

The result is lower friction, clearer rules, and a signal that private capital is welcome.

Growth in a free-market economy comes from people willing to risk their own money on projects that create value. Extra local tests, premium consultant fees, and uneven application of the rules make that risk higher and the return less certain. Removing obstacles the state does not require is one of the clearest, lowest-cost steps Topeka can take to compete. The Governing Body can make that change, and the evidence supports doing so.

*Henry McClure, MCRE, LLC · (762) 291-2765*



Henry McClure
785.383.9994 

Sent from my T-Mobile 5G Device
Get Outlook for Android

No comments:

Four Years, $35 Million in Bonds, No Lagoon: The State Sues Over Derby Shores

By Henry McClure, MCRE Media | Nov. 16, 2026 Picture a 4½-acre crystal-blue lagoon with a hotel, apartments, a tiki bar, a zipline and water...