Saturday, November 7, 2026

Re: please review

I will not be attending that meeting - 

I declined the invitation 

Take all the time needed 

These a policy changes. 

I see Braxton is copied on this email and to avoid any involvement with him I'm happy to wait after his retirement. 

H 

MCRE, LLC
3625 SW 29th Street
Topeka KS 66614
762.291.2765

From: Leigha Boling <lboling@topeka.org>
Sent: Saturday, November 7, 2026 5:06 PM
To: Henry McClure <mcre13@gmail.com>
Cc: Dan Warner <DWarner@topeka.org>; Michael G Hall <mghall@topeka.org>; Braxton Copley <bcopley@topeka.org>; City Manager <citymanager@topeka.org>
Subject: RE: please review
 

Good afternoon, Henry.

 

We have received your email and are seeking guidance from Legal regarding your requests.

 

I see that a meeting is scheduled for Tuesday, November 10, at 3:00 p.m. Please be aware that this timeline may not allow sufficient time for us to fully review your requests and provide a response in time for the meeting.

 

I will let you know if any additional information is needed and will provide an update as soon as I have more information to share.


Best regards,

Leigha Boling

Economic Development Director

City of Topeka

215 SE 7th Street, Topeka, KS 66603

lboling@topeka.org

Phone: (785) 368-0974

 

NOTICE: This message and any attachments may be confidential and contain legally privileged information. If you are not an employee of the City of Topeka (see K.S.A. 75-6102(d)), we do not waive any legal protection that may apply such as attorney-client or work product privileges. If you have received this email in error, please immediately notify the sender and delete the message and any attachments. Further, this communication is not intended to constitute, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice to you.

 

From: Henry McClure <mcre13@gmail.com>
Sent: Friday, November 6, 2026 6:47 PM
To: Leigha Boling <lboling@topeka.org>; City Manager <citymanager@topeka.org>
Cc: Dan Warner <DWarner@topeka.org>; Michael G Hall <mghall@topeka.org>
Subject: please review

 

Notice: -----This message was sent by an external sender-----

 

Leigha,

 

Ahead of any future meetings, I'm enclosing the Blight Study Overview, the Driggs site plans, and our list of requested policy exceptions for the TIF at SW 37th and Gage.

 

The heart of this is the road. The City engineered Elevation Parkway through this land. In 2022 the Council voted 9-0 to fund its design. We bought this property because that road was coming. Then in 2024 the design money went to a fleet garage, the 2025 CIP cut the project from $18.7 million to $3 million, and the proposed 2027-2036 CIP drops it entirely. The land is still planned around a street the City will not build, split by a City-mapped stream buffer, and graded through 15 feet of rock.

 

That is economic obsolescence and a defective street layout created by public decisions, not by the market. It is exactly the kind of site TIF exists for.

We are not asking the City to build the road. We are asking for:

  1. A TIF district covering eligible site costs: grading, utilities, storm water and buffer work, and erosion control.
  2. A waiver of the "but for" test under Section Eight of Resolution 9626. State law does not require it, and the City's own record shows the gap.
  3. A waiver, credit, or refund of the application deposit, which the policy allows under Section Five.

I'd like to get this moving now, not next quarter. Please review these materials and let me know what else you need from me.

 

H

 

Henry McClure 

Time Kills Deals 

762-291-2765 

 

444

Friday, November 6, 2026

Title: Topeka’s Tax Base Problem: Why the Capital Carries More Than Its Share

Opening: Topeka is Kansas’s capital. That status brings prestige, jobs, and visitors—and a large volume of property that never appears on the tax rolls.

The exemption reality
Under Kansas law, property used exclusively by the state is exempt. So are qualifying hospital and charitable properties. Stormont Vail Health, a major nonprofit system with substantial assets, owns multiple parcels that qualify. The practical effect is a smaller taxable base that still funds local services used by everyone, including state agencies and large nonprofits.

What other capitals do
Vermont, Connecticut, and Massachusetts have statutory PILOT programs that send money back to communities hosting state property. Montpelier receives meaningful annual payments. Kansas has no comparable requirement. Federal PILOT payments for federal land exist but are minimal in Shawnee County.

How the remaining dollars have been used
Public reporting on Hotel Topeka shows a multi-year investment in the $14–17 million range, operating losses, and a sale that recovers only a fraction of the outlay in the near term. Lauren’s Bay has featured large unpaid balances and repeated incentive discussions. Go Topeka, funded by the half-cent sales tax through JEDO, has faced years of questions about its relationship to the Chamber and the transparency of its spending.

What would change the picture
A state PILOT program modeled on Vermont or Connecticut would share the cost of hosting the capital. Greater public tracking of exempt value, incentive outcomes, and project returns would make trade-offs clearer. Basic infrastructure still needs funding.

Closing: Other capitals have already decided the host city should not carry the entire burden. Topeka can ask the same question.



What Trump can do in Texas ..... will we be safe?

Yes. The primary mechanism is straightforward federal authority over the border itself. A Democratic governor (in this case, Texas Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa, and similarly the new or continuing Democratic governors in California, Arizona, and New Mexico) cannot unilaterally “open the border.” Immigration enforcement, border control, and related operations are federal responsibilities under the Constitution.

What a governor can and cannot do

  • A governor can withdraw state resources that previous Republican governors (especially Greg Abbott in Texas) had committed: state National Guard troops under state control, state troopers, state-funded barriers or operations like Operation Lone Star, and voluntary local law-enforcement cooperation (e.g., ending or limiting 287(g) agreements). They can also pursue sanctuary-style policies and challenge federal actions in court.
  • A governor cannot stop federal agents (Border Patrol/CBP, ICE) from operating on the border or in the interior, alter federal immigration law or enforcement priorities, or prevent the federal government from processing, detaining, or removing people under federal statutes. Federal law preempts conflicting state efforts under the Supremacy Clause.

Trump addressed this directly after the election when asked about Hinojosa potentially pulling state manpower: “I’m sure they’ll continue my policy. And if they don’t continue my policy, I will.”

Practical tools available to the President

  1. Scale federal enforcement — Direct DHS, Border Patrol, and ICE to maintain or increase personnel, technology, and operations on the border and in the interior. This has been the main driver of the sharp drop in crossings under the current administration and does not depend on state cooperation.
  2. Federalize National Guard units or use military support — Statutes such as 10 U.S.C. § 12406 allow the President to call Guard units into federal service (Title 10) under conditions involving invasion, rebellion, or inability to execute federal laws with regular forces. The Insurrection Act provides broader authority in certain circumstances. A governor cannot simply refuse a lawful federalization order (established by Supreme Court precedent such as Perpich). These steps have been used and litigated in 2025–2026; courts review whether the statutory predicates are met.
  3. Continue barrier construction and related infrastructure — Existing statutory authority (including IIRIRA waiver powers used by DHS secretaries) supports wall and road projects, subject to ongoing court challenges on specific segments.
  4. Litigation and enforcement pressure — The administration can (and has) sued jurisdictions whose policies interfere with federal officers, pursue funding conditions on grants (though courts have blocked many of these), and designate/sanctuary-list jurisdictions that obstruct enforcement.

State legislative changes (e.g., repealing Texas laws requiring certain local cooperation) generally need the legislature, which may limit how quickly a new governor can reverse existing statutes. Hinojosa takes office in January 2027, so any transition occurs while federal operations continue.

In short, the “safety” mechanism is the constitutional and statutory allocation of border and immigration power to the federal government. Withdrawing state assistance creates logistical friction but does not reopen the border if the President directs federal agencies to maintain enforcement. 

Wednesday, November 4, 2026

Go Topeka must go

**Leigha Boling** (Director of Economic Development for the City of Topeka).

As of January 2026, the city appointed her to this role (she previously served as Procurement Director). She handles economic development priorities including redevelopment projects, incentive programs (such as TIF, CID, and RHID), and related partnerships.

Note that economic development is now a standalone director-level function (separate from Planning). Dan Warner is the Director of Planning, Development, and Housing Services. Previously, Rhiannon Friedman held overlapping roles as Director of Development and Economic Growth and then Planning and Development Director (she left in mid-2025).

Boling remains in the economic development role based on 2026 meeting records. For the most current contact details, check the City of Topeka website or main line (785-368-3728).

Henry McClure
785.383.9994 

Sent from my T-Mobile 5G Device
Get Outlook for Android

WAR

 Here are three of the strongest arguments commonly made for why continued U.S. involvement in the 2026 Iran conflict serves American interests, framed from the perspective of an average American who mainly cares about personal safety, gas prices, and not getting dragged into endless wars for vague reasons.

1. Stopping Iran from getting nuclear weapons

The Islamic Republic has spent decades chanting “Death to America,” funding groups that attack U.S. forces and allies, and advancing a nuclear program that inspectors and U.S. officials have repeatedly called a serious threat. Once a regime like that has nuclear weapons, the risk calculation changes for everyone—deterrence becomes harder, regional proliferation becomes more likely (Saudi Arabia, Turkey, Egypt, and others have signaled they won’t sit still), and the chance of a crisis involving U.S. troops or cities rises.

Supporters of the war argue that the February 2026 strikes (and earlier 2025 ones) set the program back, and that walking away now would let Iran rebuild under mountains while the rest of the world looks the other way. For an average American, the simple version is: better to deal with the problem while Iran is weaker than to face a nuclear-armed hostile regime later.

2. Reducing attacks on Americans and vital shipping by Iranian proxies

Iran has long used groups such as Hezbollah, the Houthis, and others to attack U.S. bases, ships, and interests without putting its own flag on the attack. The Houthis’ campaign against Red Sea shipping already forced rerouting of commercial traffic and raised costs; Iranian-backed forces have hit U.S. troops and interests across the region for years.

The case for the war is that degrading Iran’s missile, drone, and proxy infrastructure makes those attacks less frequent and less effective. An average American doesn’t need a detailed regional strategy to understand the appeal: fewer attacks on U.S. service members and less disruption to the shipping lanes that carry oil and goods the U.S. economy depends on.

3. Reopening the Strait of Hormuz and protecting energy prices long-term

A large share of the world’s oil moves through the Strait of Hormuz. When Iran threatens or effectively closes it (as it has done during this conflict), oil prices jump and Americans feel it at the pump. Supporters of the campaign argue that the only durable way to stop that blackmail is to make it too costly for Iran to keep doing it—by damaging its ability to target shipping and enforcing a reopening of the strait.

In the short run the war itself has raised gas prices, which is one reason it has been unpopular. The counter-argument from proponents is that a half-finished effort leaves Iran free to repeat the tactic whenever it wants, while finishing the job (or forcing a deal that permanently reopens the strait) removes that leverage. For most Americans, stable and lower energy prices matter more than abstract geopolitics.

Tuesday, November 3, 2026

Dump the "but for"

 The City of Topeka says we have a housing crisis. Their own updated housing study (released September 2026) says the city needs 4,220 additional housing units over the next 20 years — roughly 210 units a year. Median home values jumped 63% between 2019 and 2025. Rents are up. Inventory is tight. As of the June 2026 Point-in-Time count, 460 people in Topeka/Shawnee County were still experiencing homelessness.

So how is the city responding?

By writing checks to Columbia Capital Management totaling approximately $1.85 million in municipal advisory and consulting fees across 95 invoices dating back more than a decade. Of that, $136,500 was specifically for RHID consulting — nine separate invoices, eight of them at $16,000 and one at $8,500, for projects including Riverstone (Meier’s Place), Sherwood Village Park, Union at Tower District, Project View, 3D Homes, Johnson-Betts Meadows, and Windward Estates.

These aren’t small administrative fees. They’re the price of admission to the incentive machine. The city’s RHID policy (Resolution 9695 and earlier versions) requires a “but-for” analysis showing that, without the tax increment subsidy, the project could not proceed or could not meet the city’s housing goals. Private developers must pay for this analysis. The consultant who typically runs it is Columbia Capital. The same firm that has billed the city itself nearly two million dollars over the years.

Here’s the problem: the Kansas Legislative Post Audit has described the core “but-for” question as inherently unknowable. You cannot reliably prove a counterfactual — what a developer would or would not have done in the absence of a subsidy. The city wrote the rule, requires private applicants to jump through it (and pay a consultant to produce the paperwork), and then exempts its own projects and certain preferred partners when convenient.

Meanwhile, actual housing production remains well below the levels the city’s own study says are needed. Shawnee County’s new housing permits have lagged peer counties for years. The city is now floating a sales-tax increase for an affordable housing trust fund and homeless services while continuing to route substantial public money through the same consultant-driven incentive process.

$136,500 in RHID consulting fees. Nine invoices. That is enough to cover the hard costs of multiple modest single-family homes or a meaningful number of units of genuinely affordable housing. Instead, it bought more analysis of whether developers needed more analysis of whether they needed subsidies.

If the housing crisis is real — and the city’s own numbers say it is — then the priority should be removing barriers to building, not adding layers of paid ritual that primarily benefit the consultants who administer them. The “but-for” test does not create housing. It creates billable hours. And right now, Topeka appears more committed to the latter than the former.




Fw: The But-For Test Is the Failure: Topeka Should Retire It



Henry McClure
785.383.9994 

Sent from my T-Mobile 5G Device
Get Outlook for Android

From: Megan J. Brunson <mjbrunson@topeka.org>
Sent: Tuesday, 03 November 2026 08:46:04
To: Henry McClure <mcre13@gmail.com>; Mary E. Kuckelman Spinelli <mespinelli@topeka.org>
Cc: City Clerk <cclerk@Topeka.org>; Bonnie Williams <bowilliams@topeka.org>
Subject: RE: The But-For Test Is the Failure: Topeka Should Retire It
 

Good Morning,

 

Henry stopped by the office and paid the $36.00 for his records.

 

Thank you!

 

Megan Brunson

Administrative Officer, Special Events

mjbrunson@topeka.org

785-368-3940

 

“The preceding email message (including any attachments) contains information that may be confidential, protected by the attorney/client or other applicable privileges or that may constitute non-public information. This message is intended to be conveyed only to the designated recipient(s). If you are not listed as a recipient of this message, please notify the sender immediately by replying to this message and then delete it from your system. Use, dissemination, distribution, or reproduction of this message by unintended recipients is not authorized and may be unlawful.”

Uploaded Image

 

From: Henry McClure <mcre13@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, November 2, 2026 7:07 PM
To: Mary E. Kuckelman Spinelli <mespinelli@topeka.org>
Cc: City Clerk <cclerk@topeka.org>; Bonnie Williams <bowilliams@topeka.org>
Subject: RE: The But-For Test Is the Failure: Topeka Should Retire It

 

Notice: -----This message was sent by an external sender-----

 

Mary,

Thank you for the quick response. I'll bring a check for the $36 to the Clerk's office at 215 SE 7th Street, Room 166, tomorrow morning. Please go ahead and pull the invoices, including the one paid after September 28, and thanks for having staff check the older system for anything before 2021.

I still need an answer on one part of my request: fees paid at bond closing. Please provide the closing statements or cost-of-issuance schedules that show any Columbia Capital fees paid from bond proceeds, including the $480,308 coded as bond issuance costs. If no such records exist, please tell me that in writing.

I'd also like the total of the fund 499 invoices that developers paid through the Economic Development incentive application.

Thank you,

 

Henry McClure 

Time kills deals

785-383-9994

 

www.henrymcclure.live

 

On Mon, Nov 2, 2026 at 4:43 PM Mary E. Kuckelman Spinelli <mespinelli@topeka.org> wrote:

Mr. McClure,

 

You can make payment for the staff time needed to gather the actual invoices by calling the Clerk’s office at 785-368-3940 to provide a credit card number or mail or hand-deliver a check or cash to the Clerk’s office at 215 SE 7th Street, Room 166, Topeka, KS 66603.

 

Regarding your questions in #1 below about the funds that the invoices were charged to, the Finance Department has clarified that while the invoices are not charged to specific bonds/projects, they are charged to numbered funds that correspond with a category of projects or bonds. 301 represents the Debt Service fund, 499 represents the Economic Development Clearing fund (invoices charged to this fund are generally paid by the relevant developer through the Economic Development incentive application), and 821 is the Water Utility CIP fund where capital projects for water are charged to.

 

Regarding #2, the report previously provided only went back to 2021 because the retention period for this category of data is 5 years. City staff will look into what additional invoices are available in an older system that is in the process of being phased out.

 

Regarding #3, there is an additional invoice that was paid after the below mentioned date and that invoice will be provided with the others once payment is received and staff has gathered what is responsive.

 

Thanks,

 

Mary E. Kuckelman Spinelli

Senior Attorney

Mailing Address:

215 SE 7th Street, Room 353

Topeka, KS  66603

(785) 368-3883

 

NOTICE: This message and any attachments may be confidential and contain legally privileged information. If you are not an employee of the City of Topeka (see K.S.A. 75-6102(d)), we do not waive any legal protection that may apply such as attorney-client or work product privileges. If you have received this email in error, please immediately notify the sender and delete the message and any attachments. Further, this communication is not intended to constitute, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice to you.

 

 

From: Henry McClure <mcre13@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, October 29, 2026 4:05 PM
To: Mary E. Kuckelman Spinelli <mespinelli@topeka.org>
Cc: City Clerk <cclerk@topeka.org>
Subject: Re: The But-For Test Is the Failure: Topeka Should Retire It

 

Notice: -----This message was sent by an external sender-----

 

Ms. Spinelli,

Thank you for the invoice report and the agreements. Please go ahead and pull copies of the actual invoices. I'll pay the $36 to the Clerk's office. Let me know how you'd like payment.

The response leaves three parts of my request open:

1. Fees paid from bond proceeds. Your email says the invoices are paid from the general fund and not from specific bonds. But the report you sent shows about $2.2 million charged to funds 301, 499 and 821, and $480,308 coded "Clearing Exp - COI Bonds." Please provide records of any fees paid to Columbia Capital at bond closing or out of bond proceeds, including closing statements or cost-of-issuance schedules, and identify what funds 301, 499 and 821 are.

2. Years before 2021. My request covered the start of the engagement. Please provide payment records from the first Columbia Capital engagement through 2020.

3. Payments after September 28, 2026, if any.

If any of these records don't exist, please say so in writing.

Thank you,
Henry McClure
(762) 291-2765

 

Henry McClure 

Time kills deals

785-383-9994

 

www.henrymcclure.live

 

On Thu, Oct 29, 2026 at 5:46 PM Henry McClure <mcre13@gmail.com> wrote:

Received  - thanks 

 

H

 

MCRE, LLC

3625 SW 29th Street

Topeka KS 66614

762.291.2765


From: Mary E. Kuckelman Spinelli <mespinelli@topeka.org>
Sent: Thursday, October 29, 2026 12:17 PM
To: mcre13@gmail.com <mcre13@gmail.com>
Cc: Braxton Copley <bcopley@topeka.org>; City Clerk <cclerk@Topeka.org>
Subject: RE: The But-For Test Is the Failure: Topeka Should Retire It

 

Dear Mr. McClure,

 

This is in response to your below open records request. Staff has identified the attached/linked records as responsive to your request.

 

The attached invoice report includes all requested data fields that the City tracks for invoices from 2021 through 2026. The City does not charge invoices to specific projects, therefore that information is not tracked in a report form. Similarly, invoices are paid from the general fund and not specific bonds. The invoices themselves may include additional information related to the purpose of the services provided or what project or bond the services might be associated with. If you would like to obtain copies of the invoice, staff estimates that to research and identify the responsive invoices it would take two hours of staff time at the rate of $18.00 per hour for a total of $36.00. If you would like to proceed, please contact the Clerk’s office to make payment.

 

Please also find linked the responsive agreements with Columbia Capital: https://cityoftopeka.sharefile.com/d-s7be9c7c7bb3946b081a36a74758c047d

 

Thank you,

 

Mary E. Kuckelman Spinelli

Senior Attorney

Mailing Address:

215 SE 7th Street, Room 353

Topeka, KS  66603

(785) 368-3883

 

NOTICE: This message and any attachments may be confidential and contain legally privileged information. If you are not an employee of the City of Topeka (see K.S.A. 75-6102(d)), we do not waive any legal protection that may apply such as attorney-client or work product privileges. If you have received this email in error, please immediately notify the sender and delete the message and any attachments. Further, this communication is not intended to constitute, nor should it be relied upon, as legal advice to you.

 

 

 

 

 

From: Henry McClure <mcre13@gmail.com>
Sent: Saturday, 24 October 2026 19:58:58
To: Braxton Copley <
bcopley@topeka.org>; Marcus Miller <marcusm@topeka.org>; Governing Body <governingbody@topeka.org>; City Clerk <cclerk@Topeka.org>; John Kollhoff <johnkollhoff@gmail.com>
Cc: Leigha Boling <
lboling@topeka.org>; Jeff White (jwhite@columbiacapital.com) <jwhite@columbiacapital.com>
Subject: Re: The But-For Test Is the Failure: Topeka Should Retire It

 

Notice: -----This message was sent by an external sender-----

 

Dear City Clerk,

 

Under the Kansas Open Records Act, K.S.A. 45-215 et seq., I am submitting a new, separate request.

 

Background: The City's September 23, 2026 response to my request McClure KORA 091826 stated that Finance records and January through June 2026 were included. However, the spreadsheet I received contains only Public Works and Utilities payments for 2024 and 2025. No payments to Columbia Capital Management, which serves as the City's financial advisor, appear in it.

I request:

  1. A check register or payment report of every payment the City of Topeka has made to Columbia Capital Management, LLC, including any affiliates, predecessor names, or individual principals such as Jeff White, from the first date the City engaged the firm through the present, across all departments and funds (including Finance, bond and debt issuance, and capital project funds).
  1. For each payment: the date, amount, fund or account charged, and the project, bond issue, or purpose, if recorded.
  1. A grand total of all payments, and totals by year if readily available.
  1. Copies of all engagement agreements, contracts, or amendments with Columbia Capital, including scope of services and fee schedules.

Please also note that fees paid to a financial advisor may be paid at bond closing from bond proceeds rather than through the City's regular accounts payable. If so, please include those payments as shown on closing statements or settlement memoranda.

I am requesting the register data only, not copies of individual checks. An electronic spreadsheet is preferred. If any portion is withheld, please cite the specific exemption and release the remainder. If fees will exceed $100, please let me know before proceeding.

Separately, please send the Finance and January through June 2026 portions that were described as included in the KORA 091826 response but were not in the spreadsheet I received.

 

Thank you for your help.

 

Henry McClure

MCRE Media

(762) 291-2765

mcre13@gmail.com


From: Braxton Copley <bcopley@topeka.org>
Sent: Saturday, October 24, 2026 5:24 PM
To: Henry McClure <
mcre13@gmail.com>; Marcus Miller <marcusm@topeka.org>; Governing Body <governingbody@topeka.org>; City Clerk <cclerk@Topeka.org>; John Kollhoff <johnkollhoff@gmail.com>
Cc: Leigha Boling <
lboling@topeka.org>; Jeff White (jwhite@columbiacapital.com) <jwhite@columbiacapital.com>
Subject: Re: The But-For Test Is the Failure: Topeka Should Retire It

 

Thanks Mr. McClure

 

Appreciate your sharing your opinion.  We will have to agree to disagree on this issue. The resolutions adopted by the governing body establishing the economic development programs for TIF, RHID and CID all require financial analysis to determine that the incentive is necessary to achieve a market rate of return—commonly referred to as the “but-for” test. 

 

Because a developer is asking the governing body to forego tax revenue as an inducement to construct the project, the governing body needs to assure itself that it is not using tax dollars to over-incentivize the project

 

Attached is a memo explaining capitalization rates and the “but-for” test that was shared with the governing body earlier this week.

 

This is a policy matter for the the governing body.  Until they choose to remove or modify the requirement to do the financial analysis to determine the need for the incentive, staff will continue to follow requirements set forth in the various resolutions.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Get Outlook for iOS


From: Henry McClure <mcre13@gmail.com>
Sent: Saturday, 24 October 2026 14:31:52
To: Marcus Miller <
marcusm@topeka.org>; Governing Body <governingbody@topeka.org>; City Clerk <cclerk@topeka.org>; Braxton Copley <bcopley@topeka.org>; John Kollhoff <johnkollhoff@gmail.com>
Subject: The But-For Test Is the Failure: Topeka Should Retire It

 

Notice: -----This message was sent by an external sender-----

 

The But-For Test Is the Failure: Topeka Should Retire It

Take one Topeka building as an example. A city water main broke, and deferred maintenance meant there was no way to shut it off. Water backed up inside and flooded the space, and the sheetrock was ruined. The owner has spent years paying for damage he didn't cause. If that owner ever wanted to set up a Community Improvement District (CID) to help rebuild, he would first have to pay a consultant to run a "but-for" test. That's a theoretical exercise to decide whether the project "needs" help and what his rate of return should be.

That's the problem in one sentence. A property owner who has already absorbed the cost of the city's neglect would have to pay an outsider with no money at risk to judge what his own risk is worth.

This isn't about one building or one owner. It's about a test that fails every time it meets the real world.

It measures the wrong thing. The but-for test asks whether a project would happen "but for" public help, and it answers with assumptions on paper. It can't see floods, failed infrastructure, ruined interiors, years of lost use, or what it costs to rebuild after damage someone else caused.

It puts the cost on the wrong people. Owners pay up front just to be allowed to ask. Every dollar spent on a consultant's opinion is a dollar not spent on roofs, drywall, and tenants. The consultant gets paid whether the project succeeds or fails.

It slows down the very reinvestment Topeka says it wants. Older corridors and distressed buildings are exactly where reinvestment is hardest and matters most. A costly gatekeeping step makes small, local owners less likely to try at all. Only those who can afford the paperwork move forward.

It's outdated. Tools like CIDs already come with public hearings, council approval, and limits set in law. Adding a paid rate-of-return opinion on top of that is redundant. It's bureaucracy, not accountability.

There's a better standard. Judge projects on what they deliver and verify it: restored buildings, jobs, a stronger tax base, and blight removed. Make the owner prove results, not pay for a forecast.

Topeka should retire the but-for test. The people with skin in the game have been through enough. Future owners shouldn't have to pay for a litmus test that was never built to understand them.

Henry McClure, mcre Media | (762) 291-2765 | mcremedia.blogspot.com

 

 

 


From: Henry McClure <mcre13@gmail.com>
Sent: Saturday, October 24, 2026 1:24 PM
To: Braxton Copley <
bcopley@topeka.org>; City Clerk <cclerk@topeka.org>; David Banks <dbanks@topeka.org>; Governing Body <governingbody@topeka.org>; Spencer Duncan <sduncan@topeka.org>
Subject: Re: You should be fired. 

 

This property has already absorbed significant damage in recent years from a City water main failure. Deferred maintenance left the main unable to be isolated, the break flooded the building, and the resulting interior damage—including to the sheetrock—was extensive and costly. Those problems were not caused by weather or by anything the ownership did; they were caused by the condition of the City’s infrastructure.

The ownership is now being asked to absorb still more disruption from a City project, again without notice or permission. Against that history, it is especially hard to accept analyses from outside consultants who have no connection to the property, no knowledge of what it has already endured, and no stake in the outcome. A rate-of-return calculation that ignores prior City-caused damage, and that treats the property as if it has operated in a normal environment, is not a useful measure of anything. The owner is not seeking special treatment. He is simply trying to keep a property functional after repeated problems that originated with the City.

 


From: Braxton Copley <bcopley@topeka.org>
Sent: Saturday, October 24, 2026 1:14 PM
To: Henry McClure <
mcre13@gmail.com>; City Clerk <cclerk@topeka.org>; David Banks <dbanks@topeka.org>; Governing Body <governingbody@topeka.org>; Spencer Duncan <sduncan@topeka.org>
Subject: Re: You should be fired. 

 

Mr McClure

 

Thank you for the communication.  Please give me an opportunity to look into this matter.  I will be in touch

 

B

 

Get Outlook for iOS


From: Henry McClure <mcre13@gmail.com>
Sent: Saturday, 24 October 2026 14:02:48
To: Braxton Copley <
bcopley@topeka.org>; City Clerk <cclerk@topeka.org>; David Banks <dbanks@topeka.org>; Governing Body <governingbody@topeka.org>; Spencer Duncan <sduncan@topeka.org>
Subject: You should be fired. 

 

Notice: -----This message was sent by an external sender-----

 

Braxton

 

This is shameful

 

H

 

Henry McClure 

Time Kills Deals 

762-291-2765 

 

444

RE: Are we over-incentivizing Columbia Capital?

    Leigha Boling Economic Development Director City of Topeka 215 SE 7th Street, Topeka, KS 66603 lboling@topeka.org ...