Sunday, November 15, 2026

But let's not forget that it's unknowable

Got it. This version leads with Canyon Research as the better value:

---

**Topeka Can Get Its Numbers Run for a Fraction of the Price**

When Overland Park needed a feasibility study for a STAR bond project, it hired Canyon Research for a flat $7,000. The price was set before the work started, with no meter running. That's the kind of deal Topeka taxpayers and local developers deserve.

Topeka instead relies on Columbia Capital to decide whether a project "needs" incentives, and developers usually pay for it through a $25,000 deposit. Columbia's contract and rate sheet with the City still haven't been made public; members of Policy & Finance asked for them on Nov 4. Here's how the alternatives compare, according to public records.

**Gap and feasibility studies (the "but-for" test), best value first:**
1. **Canyon Research:** $7,000 flat, Overland Park STAR bond study (2012). It's the lowest price on record and you know it up front. Today's price would be higher, and Topeka should ask for a bid.
2. **Baker Tilly:** hourly, $160 to $235 for analysts and $295 to $525 for partners, Joplin, MO but-for review (2021). It's a good value if the City caps the hours.
3. **Columbia Capital:** Topeka's price is unknown because the contract hasn't been released.

**Bond advisory fees (assuming a $10 million bond issue):**
1. **Columbia Capital, Harvey County, KS (2026):** $15,000 plus $0.90 per $1,000 of bonds, about $24,000. Columbia charges a competitive rate elsewhere in Kansas, so why can't Topeka see what it pays?
2. **Hilltop Securities, Flint, MI (2022):** $3.00 per $1,000 of bonds, with a $30,000 minimum and $85,000 maximum, so about $30,000.
3. **PFM, Flint, MI (2022):** up to $100,000.

**What Topeka should do:** put this work out for competitive bids, invite Canyon Research and Baker Tilly, and publish the Columbia contract and invoices. A city that wants more housing shouldn't make builders pay top dollar for a consultant to tell them whether they deserve help. Every dollar spent on studies is a dollar that doesn't go into the ground.

Henry McClure | MCRE, LLC | (762) 291-2765

---

Want any changes, or should I get it ready for the blog? Nothing gets posted until you say so.

Henry McClure
785.383.9994 

Sent from my T-Mobile 5G Device
Get Outlook for Android

No comments:

RE: Are we over-incentivizing Columbia Capital?

    Leigha Boling Economic Development Director City of Topeka 215 SE 7th Street, Topeka, KS 66603 lboling@topeka.org ...